Will Brazilian politics and related violence ever change? I think not.
Subscribe to the topic
Post new topic
Will Brazilian politics and related violence ever change? I think not.
Despite the fact that Brazil is one of the ratifying nations of the United Nations Convention Against Corruption (UNCAC) it is highly unlikely that there will ever be any real changes in the political landscape of this country. The sad truth is that the corruption is not only systemic, but historical. Since Brazils discovery and colonization the general population has turned a blind eye to the problem. I see no logical reason that anything will change now. Even the recent shuffle in the various government ministries by newly elected President Dilma Rousseff and the Federal Police investigations into gross irregularities in the Ministries of Tourism, Transport and of Agriculture will probably not produce any significant changes. In fact, all of them seem to be purely cosmetic in nature and more an exercise in face-saving than they are intended to be serious measures to root out and punish corruption.
Historical events have fostered within the average Brazilian citizen an attitude of Its always been this way
it will always be this way
I am just one small voice
it does no good to complain so, I guess I will just keep my mouth shut and accept it. There is no public outcry like there would be in almost any other democratic nation, not here! Brazilians, by nature, are people who are extremely reluctant to complain publicly as a collective. This is a characteristic that has been exterminated in the general population as a direct result of past reprisals against those who have tried to complain in an organized way.
It would be bad enough if the problem of corruption was limited to just the federal level, unfortunately it exists at every level of government and taints everyone from the lowliest city employee to the top federal officials. Moreover, the greatest majority of the corrupt politicians and police either have immunity from prosecution which is entrenched in law or, at the very least, they have the right to a trial in a separate court system (foro privilegiado). Brazilian laws have been crafted with the specific intention of protecting the corrupt, or at least so it would seem. Without the creation of myriad new and rigorous anti-corruption laws and the abolition of this systemic immunity there can be no hope for change on the political horizon.
Not at all surprising that, when someone comes along who really wants to bring about serious change or poses a real threat to the jeitinho brasileiro they are assassinated, rendered powerless by some legal maneuver or simply disappear. The recent assassination of Patricia Acioli a hard-line judge in Rio de Janeiro is just the latest example of this brutal reality. Judge Acioli was to preside over around 50 cases involving suspicious deaths at the hands of members of both the Civil and Military Police forces in the region. The mere fact that she was gunned down in a hail of (twenty-one) bullets is a clear demonstration to the rest of society what is the logical end result to anyone seeking real change. The lead pill is the most common remedy for the headache caused by do-gooder politicians, judges, union leaders, journalists and environmental activists all across Brazil. The list of names is long, Sister Dorothy Stang (a Catholic nun born in Dayton OH and assassinated in Anapú, Pará in Feb. 2005 ); Nelson José da Silva, Eratóstenes de Almeida Gonsalves, João Batista Soares Lage and their driver Aílton Pereira de Oliveira (Ministry of Labor officials ambushed in Unaí, Minas Gerais in Jan. 2004); José Claudio Ribeiro and Maria do Espirito Santo (husband and wife environmental activists murdered in Nova Ipixuna, Pará in May, 2011); Tim Lopes (reporter for Globo TV network murdered in Rio de Janeiro in June, 2002); Antonio Luiz Cesar de Castro and Valdemir Antonio da Silva (mayors of two cities in Mato Groso assassinated within 2 weeks in July, 2011) and Braz Paschoalin (mayor of Jandira, São Paulo assassinated Dec. 2010) and the list goes on. Worse still, of these mentioned only the killer of Tim Lopes has been brought to justice, the other cases have all but disappeared in the inept judicial process in Brazil.
What can we expect from a society where Federal Deputies can siphon off enough funds from the public coffers to build castles or Mayors to deposit billions of US Dollars in off-shore bank accounts and they not only do they go unpunished, but the public still votes for them in future elections? Signing the UNCAC is nothing less than a cruel joke, a slap in the face to the common citizen. How the United Nations can sit idly by, saying or doing nothing, while corruption runs rampant in one of the signatory countries is beyond me. I guess that the Convention itself is more for appearance sake and the UN is really more concerned about not offending major world economies than eliminating wide-spread corruption.
Excellent article! Corruption in Brazil is in the roots of the culture. When you ask for a receipt, a common response is "for how much". Until a strong and "protected" Gandhi - like leader arrives to wake Brazilians up to the benefits of not being corrupt, it will prevail in politics as well. This is the major barrier to Brazil entering the First World.
Douglas,
I hear ya brother! I know exactly what you are saying, having also lived in Belo Horizonte for almost 4 of my 10 years in Brazil. It seemed even worse there in Minas Gerais than it is here in São Paulo. The only place that I have lived where it was worse still was Bahia and I know that Pará and Mato Grosso make things in Bahia look like a stroll in the park.
In economic terms, I am glad to say that Brazil is well on its way to becoming a First World country, however in terms of its internal politics we lag way behind many African nations that are torn by strife and civil wars, sad to say.
I doubt that we will ever see a Brazilian Gandhi, they aren't made from the same mold here and until the government takes education seriously enough to allocate decent funding to it, they will never produce a close facsimile to Gandhi here either.
It´s just like a Mettalica song: "SAD BUT TRUE"
Yet more prime examples of corruption and Brazil's government tolerating it at all levels. Federal Deputy Jaqueline Roriz was absolved of any wrongdoing and kept her congressional seat in a SECRET vote by her cronies(i.e. partners in c r _ _ _). As if the secret vote in itself wasn't bad enough, Congress went so far as to order all cameras and journalists out of the chamber in order to carry out their dirty work out of the public view. Roriz, caught in the act taking bribes and kickbacks never was in any real danger of losing her seat.... we all know who's guarding the hen house in Brasilia. Just one more reason that I thank God every day that I have no obligation to vote in this country.
The sad part is that I truly believe that the outcome would not have been any different had there been an open "show of hands" vote that was televised nationwide. Politicians in this country demonstrate such overt contempt for their constituants that they would have voted......."Sou contra cassação, e dai?" anyway.
In Campinas, the mayor was thrown out of office for corruption and the vice-mayor took over the helm. The same vice-mayor who is also being investigated by the Federal Police for corruption. Inital news was that he too was prevented from assuming office, however that decision was struck down and guess who is running the show in Campinas now? Gives a whole new meaning to the old saw "better the devil you know..."
Regarding the assassination of Judge Patricia Acioli in Rio de Janeiro, the Conselho Nacional de Justiça (CNJ) has demanded an investigation to determine negligence on the part of the presidents of the Tribunal de Justiça do Rio de Janeiro (TJ-RJ). Judge Acioli's continued written requests for protection were ignored. Head honcho at TJ-RJ, Manoel Alberto, stated publicly that security was removed at the judges own request. When the family's lawyer produced a ream of official memos that Acioli sent to the presidency expressing her grave concern and requesting protection Sr. Alberto is suddenly silent. Investigation or not, guess who will come out of this one "lily white"?
Latest addition to the list of victims... Jorge Peres, 48 years old, businessman and mayoral candidate in São Bernardo do Campo who was assassinated last night in that city. Peres was gunned down in a restaurant, you guessed it - nobody has been arrested and police have no clues (as ususal). You can bet your bottom dollar Peres either would have been an honest mayor or he knew too much about some corruption going on in the city.
You've got to be joking folks! Did you see who showed up at Paulo Maluf's 80th birthday bash???
The guest list looked like the social column. Vice-President Michel Temer, Governor Geraldo Alckmin, Ex-Governor José Maria Marim, Senator Aécio Neves, Mayor Gilberto Kassab among the hundereds of other politicians invited to the "shindig" which featured a French dinner and the São Paulo Symphony Orchestra.
Yes folks, this is the same Paulo Maluf who syphoned off billions of US dollars of public funds and deposited them in off-shore bank accounts. Although he was arrested for a short period in 2004 and held in custody of the Federal Police in São Paulo he will never be held accountable. The rest of his political cronies obviously have no moral issues about being seen publicly associating with someone we all know as one of the biggest crooks in the state. Why should they? None of them are any better.
In any other country the politicians would be conspicuous by their absence.
Yes, it is sad that a country so beautiful and with so much to offer has this corruption of which you speak. But, as with other countries I have visited, at least the corruption is out in the open. Here in the USA corruption is part of the law. In other words, corruption in the USA is legal if you know the law.
Plain and simple - corruption is everywhere, every country, every state, everyone who has money - corrupt on one way or another. Guarantee that.
Sad to say that things still haven't changed much since this topic was posted.
The most recent incidents have been the assassination of Federal Police Agent, Wilton Tapajós Macedo, shot twice as he visited the grave of his parents in a Brasilia cemetery. Macedo was one of the officers in Operation Monte Carlo which investigated gambling kingpin Carlinhos Cachoeira.
Oh yes, then too there's the case where the judge in this case recused himself because of death threats, the wife of Cachoeira has also been charged with trying to bribe the new judge in the case.
According to the most recent figures that I could find... so far in the run up to the 2012 elections (mayor / council members) in all of Brazil there have been 14 candidates assassinated. Shocking but it happens every election.
Did I hear somebody say Wild West???
Articles to help you in your expat project in Brazil
- Using phones in Brazil
It's much easier these days to get a cell phone in Brazil, and phones and calling plans are inexpensive. ...
- Accommodation in Brasilia
Brasilia, the country's federal capital, is home to many highly-paid government employees and foreign ...
- Dating in Brazil
If you're single and ready to mingle, then you might want to try your hand at dating after you've settled ...
- Marriage in Brazil
Brazil can be a romantic country, and you may want to marry here. Perhaps you even want to remain in Brazil ...
- Leisure activities in Brazil
Have you always dreamed of dancing to the rhythm of a Brazilian carnival? Do you wish to enjoy the sand and the ...
- Accommodation in Rio de Janeiro
With an official population of about seven million people, and almost twice that number in the metro area, Rio de ...
- Childcare in Brazil
As more and more women have joined the workforce in Brazil, childcare has become very important. There are a few ...
- Driving in Brazil
If you‘re moving to Brazil for a short time, then you can use your national driving license. However, if you ...